Patient guide

Psychiatrist, psychologist or therapist?

Three different jobs that are easy to confuse. Here is what each one does, and how to decide where to start.

The short answer

A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who diagnoses mental illness and can prescribe medication. A psychologist holds a doctoral degree and provides therapy and psychological testing. A therapist is a licensed counselor, social worker or family therapist who provides talk therapy.

Many people do best with two of them working together: a psychiatrist for diagnosis and medication, and a therapist for regular therapy.

Side by side

PsychiatristPsychologistTherapist
TrainingMedical school (MD or DO), then four years of residency in psychiatryDoctoral degree in psychology (PhD or PsyD) and supervised practiceMaster's degree and supervised clinical practice
Prescribes medicationYesNoNo
DiagnosesYes, including medical causes, medication effects and substance useYesYes, within the scope of the license
Main workEvaluation, diagnosis, medication treatment, psychotherapy and coordinating careTherapy, and psychological or cognitive testingRegular talk therapy
Typical visitsA longer first evaluation, then follow-up visits that combine medication management and therapyTesting sessions, or weekly therapyWeekly or every other week, about 50 minutes

The letters after a name

Where to start

Start with a psychiatrist if

  • Symptoms are getting in the way of work, school, sleep or relationships.
  • You may need medication, or the medication you take is not working.
  • The diagnosis is unclear, or several problems overlap.
  • Alcohol or drug use is part of the picture.
  • Your therapist has suggested a medication evaluation.

Start with a therapist if

  • You are going through a hard stretch: grief, stress, a relationship problem.
  • You want skills to manage anxiety or low mood.
  • Symptoms are mild and you would rather begin without medication.

Your primary care doctor can also start common medications for depression and anxiety. A psychiatrist is worth seeing when the first treatments have not helped, the diagnosis is in question, or a medical illness, medication or substance may be part of the cause.

If you are in crisis, call or text 988, or go to the nearest emergency department.

How we work

Cognitive Works is a psychiatric practice. We do the evaluation, the diagnosis and the medication plan, and most visits also include psychotherapy blended with medication management. We work closely with therapists. If you already see a therapist, we coordinate with them with your permission. If you need one, we help you find one. You can read more about our approach and our services.

Request an evaluationCall 952-300-6277

Questions we are asked

Do I need a referral to see a psychiatrist?

Usually not. Some insurance plans ask for one. Call us and we will check your plan before your first visit.

Can a psychiatrist also provide therapy?

Yes. At Cognitive Works, most visits blend psychotherapy into medication management: supportive psychotherapy and the fundamentals of cognitive behavioral therapy. That is why follow-up visits take at least 30 minutes. When weekly therapy would help, we work alongside your therapist.

Is a psychiatric nurse practitioner the same as a psychiatrist?

No, though both diagnose and prescribe. A psychiatrist is a physician who completed medical school and a psychiatry residency. A psychiatric nurse practitioner is an advanced practice nurse with graduate training in psychiatric care.

What is psychological testing for?

Testing measures attention, memory, thinking and personality in a structured way. We refer for it when the result would change the diagnosis or the treatment plan.

Book Appointment
Verify Insurance